WCSU

Sickle Cell Patients Endure Discrimination, Poor Care And Shortened Lives

Nov 4, 2017
Originally published on November 6, 2017 8:06 am

For more than a year, NeDina Brocks-Capla avoided one room in her large, brightly colored San Francisco house — the bathroom on the second floor.

"It was really hard to bathe in here, and I found myself not wanting to touch the walls," she explains. The bathroom is where Brocks-Capla's son Kareem Jones died in 2013 at age 36 from sickle cell disease.

It's not just the loss of her son that upsets Brocks-Capla. She believes that if Jones had gotten the proper medical care, he might still be alive today.

Sickle cell disease is an inherited disorder that causes some red blood cells to bend into a crescent shape. The misshapen, inflexible cells clog the blood vessels, preventing blood from circulating oxygen properly, which can cause chronic pain, organ failure and stroke.

About 100,000 people in the United States have sickle cell disease, and most of them are African-American.

Patients and experts alike say it's no surprise then that while life expectancy for almost every major malady is improving, patients with sickle cell disease can expect to die younger than they did more than 20 years ago. In 1994, life expectancy for sickle cell patients was 42 for men and 48 for women. A 2013 study found that life expectancy had dipped to 38 for men and 42 for women in 2005.

Sickle cell disease is "a microcosm of how issues of race, ethnicity and identity come into conflict with issues of health care," says Keith Wailoo, a professor at Princeton University who has written about the history of the disease.

It is also an example of the broader discrimination experienced by African-Americans in the medical system. Nearly a third reported that they have experienced discrimination when going to the doctor, according to a poll by NPR, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

"One of the national crises in health care is the care for adult sickle cell," says researcher and physician Dr. Elliott Vichinsky, who started the sickle cell center at UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital Oakland in California in 1978. "This group of people can live much longer with the management we have, and they're dying because we don't have access to care."

Indeed, with the proper care, Vichinsky's center and the handful of other specialty clinics like it across the country have been able to increase life expectancy for sickle cell patients well into their 60s.

Vichinsky's patient Derek Perkins, 45, knows he has already beaten the odds. He sits in an exam room decorated with cartoon characters at Children's Hospital Oakland, but this is the adult sickle cell clinic. He has been coming to see Vichinsky since childhood.

"Without the sickle cell clinic here in Oakland, I don't know what I would do. I don't know anywhere else I could go," Perkins says.

When Perkins was 27, he once ended up at a hospital where doctors misdiagnosed his crisis. He went into a coma and was near death before his mother insisted he be transferred.

"Dr. Vichinsky was able to get me here to Children's Hospital, and he found out what was wrong and within 18 hours — all I needed was an emergency blood transfusion and I was awake," Perkins recalls.

Kareem Jones lived just across the bay from Perkins, but he had a profoundly different experience.

NeDina Brocks-Capla, who often goes by Brocks, says her son received excellent medical care as a child, but once he turned 18 and aged out of his pediatric program, it felt like falling off a cliff. Jones was sent to a clinic at what is now Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, but it was open only for a half-day once a week. If he was sick any other day, he had two options: Leave a voicemail for a clinic nurse or go to the emergency room. "That's not comprehensive care — that's not consistent care for a disease of this type," says Brocks-Capla.

Brocks-Capla is a retired supervisor at a workers' compensation firm. She knew how to navigate the health care system, but she couldn't get her son the care he needed. Like most sickle cell patients, Jones had frequent pain crises. Usually he ended up in the emergency room, where, Brocks-Capla says, the doctors didn't seem to know much about sickle cell disease.

When she tried to explain her son's pain to the doctors and nurses, she recalls, "they say have a seat. 'He can't have a seat! Can't you see him?' "

Studies have found that sickle cell patients have to wait up to 50 percent longer for help in the emergency department than other pain patients. The opioid crisis has made things even worse, Vichinsky adds, as patients in terrible pain are likely to be seen as drug seekers with addiction problems rather than as patients in need.

Despite his illness, Jones fought to have a normal life. He lived with his girlfriend, had a daughter and worked as much as he could between pain crises. He was an avid San Francisco Giants fan.

For years, he took a drug called hydroxyurea, but it had side effects, and after a while, Jones had to stop taking it. "And that was it, because you know there isn't any other medication out there," says Brocks-Capla.

Indeed, hydroxyurea, which the Food and Drug Administration first approved in 1967 as a cancer drug, was the only drug on the market to treat sickle cell during Jones' lifetime. In July, the FDA approved a second drug, Endari, specifically to treat patients with sickle cell disease.

Funding by the federal government and private foundations for the disease pales in comparison to those for other disorders. Cystic fibrosis offers a good comparison. It is another inherited disorder that requires complex care but most often occurs in Caucasians. Cystic fibrosis gets seven to 11 times more funding per patient than sickle cell disease, according to a 2013 study in the journal Blood. From 2010 to 2013 alone, the FDA approved five new drugs for the treatment of cystic fibrosis.

"There's no question in my mind that class and color are major factors in impairing their survival. Without question," Vichinsky says of sickle cell patients. "The death rate is increasing. The quality of care is going down."

Without a new medication, Jones got progressively worse. At 36, his kidneys began to fail, and he had to go on dialysis. He ended up in the hospital with the worst pain of his life. The doctors stabilized him and gave him pain medicine but didn't diagnose the underlying cause of the crisis. He was released to his mother's care, still in excruciating pain.

At home, Brocks-Capla ran a warm bath to try to soothe his pain and went downstairs to get him a change of clothes.

"As I'm coming up the stairs, I hear this banging," she says. "So I run into the bathroom, and he's having a seizure. And I didn't know what to do. I was like, 'Oh come on, come on. Don't do this. Don't do this to me.' "

She called 911. The paramedics came but couldn't revive him. "He died here with me," she says.

It turned out Jones had a series of small strokes. His organs were in failure, something Brocks-Capla says the hospital missed. She believes his death could have been prevented with consistent care — the kind he got as a child. Vichinsky thinks she is probably right.

"I would say 40 percent or more of the deaths I've had recently have been preventable — I mean totally preventable," he says, but he got to the cases too late. "It makes me so angry. I've spent my life trying to help these people, and the harder part is you can change this — this isn't a knowledge issue. It's an access issue."

Vichinsky's center and others like it have made major advances in screening patients for the early signs of organ failure and intervening to prevent death. Patients at these clinics live two decades longer than the average sickle cell patient.

Good care for sickle cell requires time and training for physicians, but it often doesn't pay well because many patients are on Medicaid or other government insurance programs. The result is that most adult sickle cell patients still struggle to access treatments that have been around for decades, Vichinsky says.

The phenomenon is nothing new — the disease that used to be known as sickle cell anemia has had a long and sordid past. It was first identified in 1910 and helped launch the field of molecular biology. But most of the research was used to study science rather than improving care for sickle cell patients, Vichinsky says.

In the 1960s and '70s, sickle cell became a lightning rod for the civil rights movement. At the time, the average patient died before age 20. The Black Panther Party took up the cause and began testing people at their "survival conferences" across the country.

"I'm sure we tested over four-and-a-half-thousand people for sickle cell anemia last night — and I think that the voter registration is running neck and neck with it," Black Panther Party Chairman Bobby Seale told news crews at an event in Oakland in 1972.

The movement grew, and Washington listened. "It is a sad and shameful fact that the causes of this disease have been largely neglected throughout our history," President Richard Nixon told Congress in 1971. "We cannot rewrite this record of neglect, but we can reverse it. To this end, this administration is increasing its budget for research and treatment of sickle-cell anemia."

For a while, funding did increase, newborn screening took hold and by the 1990s, life expectancy had doubled, with patients living into their 40s. But over time, funding waned, clinics closed and life expectancy started dropping again.

Vichinsky pushes against that trend for patients like Derek Perkins. The father of four looks healthy and robust, but like most sickle cell patients, he has episodes of extreme pain and has problems with his kidneys, heart, hips and breathing. Keeping him thriving requires regular checkups and constant monitoring for potential problems.

"The program Dr. Vichinsky is running here, I feel I owe my life to [it]," says Perkins. "If it wasn't for him and the things that he did for me, my family wouldn't have me."


Kaiser Health News, a nonprofit health newsroom whose stories appear in news outlets nationwide, is an editorially independent part of the Kaiser Family Foundation.

This story is part of an ongoing series, "You, Me and Them: Experiencing Discrimination in America." The series is based in part on a poll by NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. We will be releasing results from other groups — including Latinos, whites, Asian-Americans, Native Americans and LGBTQ adults — over the next several weeks.

Copyright 2017 Kaiser Health News. To see more, visit Kaiser Health News.

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

Nearly a third of African-Americans report experiencing discrimination when they've been to the doctor. It's according to a poll from NPR, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. Perhaps nowhere is that discrimination felt more profoundly than in sickle cell disease, a disorder that primarily hits African-Americans. Care is so problematic that patients are dying younger now than they did 20 years ago. Here's Jenny Gold with the first two stories for our series You, Me and Them: Experiencing Discrimination in America.

JENNY GOLD, BYLINE: For more than a year, NeDina Brocks avoided one room in her large, brightly colored San Francisco house, the bathroom on the second floor.

NEDINA BROCKS: It was really hard to bathe in here, and I found myself not wanting to touch the walls.

GOLD: The bathroom is where Brocks' son Kareem Jones died in 2013. He was 36 years old and had sickle cell disease. That means his red blood cells bent into a crescent shape, clogging his vessels and preventing blood from circulating oxygen to his organs. Patients with the disease suffer from problems including stroke, kidney disease and chronic pain. Sickle cell is a genetic disorder, and Brock says she felt responsible.

BROCKS: I got the trait. His dad has the trait. You know, so I was just like, wow, I did this to this kid. That's how it felt.

GOLD: Brock says, as a child, Kareem received excellent medical care. But once he turned 18, there was little help. He was sent to a clinic at San Francisco General.

BROCKS: But it's only a half a day one day a week. If he was sick any other days, it was just emergency.

GOLD: With limited clinic hours, Kareem's options were to leave a voicemail for a nurse or go to the emergency room.

BROCKS: That's not comprehensive care. That's not consistent care for a disease of this type.

GOLD: Brocks is a retired supervisor at a workers' comp firm. She understood the health care system, but she couldn't get her son what he needed. Often, he ended up at the hospital in extreme pain, where Brock says the doctors didn't seem to know much about sickle cell disease.

BROCKS: And then when we get into emergency and I'm trying to tell them, hey, he needs - OK, have a seat. He can't have a seat. Can't you see him?

GOLD: Studies have found that sickle cell patients have to wait up to 50 percent longer for help in the emergency department than other patients. Despite his illness, Kareem fought to have a normal life. He lived with his girlfriend, had a daughter and worked whenever he could. He was an avid Giants fan. For years, the one thing that helped him was a drug called hydroxyurea. But it had side effects. And after a while, Kareem had to stop taking it.

BROCKS: And that was it because, you know, there isn't any other medications out there.

GOLD: Indeed, until this year, the FDA had not approved another sickle cell drug for nearly two decades. Funding for the disease pales in comparison to other disorders. Take cystic fibrosis. It affects far fewer people than sickle cell - most of them white - but it gets seven to 11 times more funding per patient according to a study in the journal Blood. Dr. Elliott Vichinski is a leading sickle cell researcher.

ELLIOTT VICHINSKY: Race is, without question, a major factor. In large part, people of color have been discriminated against and have less power. There's less lobby and funding that goes into this.

GOLD: For Kareem's mom, Brocks, that's exactly what it felt like.

BROCKS: I believe that it's all racial. I mean, I hate to say it, but because it's a predominantly African-American disease, for whatever reason, we just can't get any funding.

GOLD: Brocks says that without a new medication, Kareem got progressively worse. At 36, he had to go on dialysis. He ended up in the hospital with the worst pain of his life. The doctors stabilized him but did not diagnose the underlying cause of the crisis. He was released to his mother's care but still in incredible pain. At home, Brocks ran him a warm bath to try to comfort him. She went downstairs to get him a change of clothes.

BROCKS: As I'm coming up the stairs, I hear this banging - you know a - (knocking) banging. And so I run into the bathroom. He's having a seizure. And I didn't know what to do. I was like, oh, come on. Come on. Don't do this. Don't do this to...

GOLD: She called 911. The paramedics couldn't revive him.

BROCKS: So he was laying out there in the hall, you know, for a while till, you know, I called the mortuary and everything. But - yeah, he died here with me.

GOLD: It turned out Kareem had had a series of small strokes. His organs were in failure, something Brock says the hospital missed. She believes if her son had been able to see specialists and get more consistent care - the kind he got as a child - he might still be alive today.

VICHINSKY: One of the national crises in health care is the care for adult sickle cell.

GOLD: Elliott Vichinsky, the sickle cell researcher, runs a center across the bay at Children's Hospital Oakland. It's one of only three places in California that offers specialized services for adults with the disease.

VICHINSKY: These group of people can live much longer with the management we have. And they are dying because we don't have access to care.

GOLD: But with the proper medical care, Vichinsky's center and others like it have been able to increase life expectancy by more than two decades.

I'm Jenny Gold in San Francisco.

(SOUNDBITE OF MELODIUM'S "WE ARE ALL RIGHT HERE")

SIMON: Jenny Gold is with our partner Kaiser Health News. And tomorrow on Weekend Edition Sunday, Part 2 - how many sickle cell patients with the proper treatment can thrive and the clinic that's making it possible.

(SOUNDBITE OF MELODIUM'S "WE ARE ALL RIGHT HERE") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.